Olfact
Français
Duel

Carlisle vs Harrods Black Tier

Change duel

The scent fingerprint

What brings them together, what sets them apart

Exclusive to Carlisle

In common

Exclusive to Harrods Black Tier

How they evolve on the skin

Notes shared by both perfumes.

Top notes the first half hour
Heart notes the central character (1 to 4 h)
Base notes the trail that remains (4 h and more)

What are they for?

Carlisle
Harrods Black Tier
Seasons
Spring
Not its territory
Suitable
Summer
Not its territory
Not its territory
Autumn
Very suitable
Very suitable
Winter
Very suitable
Suitable
Moments
Office
Not its territory
Suitable
Everyday
Suitable
Suitable
Evenings & dates
Very suitable
Very suitable
Night
Very suitable
Suitable
How is it calculated?

These markers are an editorial estimate calculated automatically from the perfume's real accords and their intensity, following the classic reading of scent families (hesperidics and aromatics shine in summer and at the office, ambers and gourmands in winter and in the evening…). They do not come from user votes and do not replace a test on skin.

Why choose one… or the other?

Why choose Carlisle

  • It costs less: from €310.00, while the other starts at €918.00.
  • It brings what the other lacks — amber, geranium, nutmeg.
  • Markedly more enveloping, carried by warm spicy and amber.
  • Eau de Parfum: the formula is more diluted than its rival's.
  • Our calculated profile does not see it on “spring” ground.

Why choose Harrods Black Tier

  • Extrait de Parfum against eau de parfum: more material, and a longer expected longevity.
  • Facets Carlisle does not have: saffron, violet, raspberry.
  • More versatile according to our calculated profile (7 contexts out of 8, against 5).
  • Its formula is out of the ordinary — myrrh, cashmere wood are among the least common notes in our database.
  • The more expensive of the two (from €918.00).

The verdict

  • Best price

    Carlisle — €608.00 difference in its favour

  • Most concentrated

    Harrods Black Tier — Extrait de Parfum, so more material than an eau de parfum

  • Most enveloping

    Carlisle — signature carried by warm spicy and amber

  • Most versatile

    Harrods Black Tier — it holds 7 of the 8 contexts we calculate, the other 5

  • Most original

    Harrods Black Tier — its notes are rarer in our catalogue (myrrh, cashmere wood)

Each trophy applies to a specific use, not in absolute terms.

Also compared