Duel

Rose Noir vs L'Eau Papier

The scent fingerprint

What brings them together, what sets them apart

How they evolve on the skin

Notes shared by both perfumes.

Top notes the first half hour
Heart notes the central character (1 to 4 h)
Base notes the trail that remains (4 h and more)

What are they for?

Rose Noir
L'Eau Papier
Seasons
Spring
Very suitable
Suitable
Summer
Suitable
Suitable
Autumn
Suitable
Very suitable
Winter
Not its territory
Suitable
Moments
Office
Very suitable
Very suitable
Everyday
Very suitable
Very suitable
Evenings & dates
Suitable
Suitable
Night
Not its territory
Suitable
How is it calculated?

These markers are an editorial estimate calculated automatically from the perfume's real accords and their intensity, following the classic reading of scent families (hesperidics and aromatics shine in summer and at the office, ambers and gourmands in winter and in the evening…). They do not come from user votes and do not replace a test on skin.

Why choose one… or the other?

Why choose Rose Noir

  • Richer concentration (Eau de Parfum against Eau de Toilette): higher theoretical longevity.
  • Its pyramid opens on rose, bergamot, ambergris, nowhere to be found opposite.
  • More track record: launched in 2008, it has been worn for 18 years.
  • We have no price recorded at our retailers yet.
  • Less at ease in the “winter” context according to our calculated profile.

Why choose L'Eau Papier

  • mimosa, rice, sesame: all materials absent from Rose Noir.
  • It covers more ground: 8 contexts out of 8 according to our calculated profile, against 6.
  • It is 15 years younger (2023 against 2008).
  • Its formula is out of the ordinary — sesame, rice are among the least common notes in our database.
  • No tracked point of sale to date.
  • Less concentrated (Eau de Toilette), it should last less long.

The verdict

  • Most concentrated

    Rose Noir — Eau de Parfum, so more material than an eau de toilette

  • Most versatile

    L'Eau Papier — at ease in 8 contexts out of 8, against 6

  • Most original

    L'Eau Papier — its notes are rarer in our catalogue (sesame, rice)

Each trophy applies to a specific use, not in absolute terms.

Also compared